Opinion - Saratoga Springs Politics

The below blog posts are written by John Kaufmann.
These opinions do not reflect the views of Saratoga TODAY newspaper.

Thursday, 30 November 2023 10:12

What Should Restaurants and Bars Pay For Their Use Of Public Property for Outdoor Dining?

By John Kaufmann | Saratoga Springs Politics

[T. Zealie Van Raalte has written the following on the issue of charging private businesses to use public city-owned sidewalks and parking spaces for outdoor dining.]

For a start, it’s unfortunate that the " fairness " issue seems to have been overlooked in any discussion/plan for an Outdoor Dining strategy. The city stakeholders can’t offer ALL restaurant owners an attractive opportunity for additional capacity. It’s a fact that not all restaurant locations lend themselves to taking advantage of utilizing “public property” for this purpose.

Thus, in many cases, the only option for some restaurant owners who want to grow their business by increasing their capacity (number of tables) is to “rent” additional space from a private landlord (if available) at market rates.

The argument that the current Outdoor Dining program pays for itself and then some is a limited one and extremely short-sighted. Yes, a “basic permit fee” has finally been developed to cover the associated labor costs incurred by the PWD. There is also obviously some incremental sales tax collected because of the increase in capacity. However, the level of any incremental sales tax achieved doesn’t compare to the potential total revenue the city should receive with an appropriate “user fee.” This fact demonstrates the clear “opportunity cost” to the stakeholders…lost revenue.

It's a fact that most municipalities that make public space available benefit from such rental income for the privilege of using public property. They have a realistic and fair “total fee” structure. Our city has failed to even begin the process.

For argument's sake, how much would a restaurant owner be willing to pay for the incremental capacity that they have enjoyed in the past IF they were informed that the privilege would no longer be available for free? Would they offer “nothing?  Most likely not.

If the “free option” was no longer available, they certainly can appreciate better than anyone what revenue they would be passing up. They would not be happy. Thus, it’s likely that they could be convinced to embrace an incremental fee structure where they could still benefit.

This should be a WIN, WIN opportunity for both the restaurant owners and the city stakeholders. In the past, some restaurant owners were really the only winners. The stakeholders have not realized the potential for this much-needed revenue opportunity.

It’s really this simple… finally, develop and implement a strategy to set the tables so there is a WIN, WIN situation for our entire community.

Read 1022 times

Blotter

  • Saratoga Springs Police Department Christopher Noffer, 52, of Terrel, North Carolina, was charged with assault.  Daniel Gudar, 46, of Saratoga Springs, was charged with criminal mischief, assault, and criminal possession of a weapon.  Alexis Riffelbach, 26, of Middle Grove, was charged with DWI, aggravated DWI, aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle, and moving from lane unsafely.  Lawrence Finneran, 71, of Saratoga Springs, was charged with criminal trespass, criminal tampering, and criminal mischief.  Charles Pace, 36, of Queensbury, was charged with tampering with physical evidence, criminal possession of a controlled substance, and criminal possession of a narcotic drug.  Saratoga County Sheriff’s Office…

Property Transactions

  • BALLSTON Joann Mare sold property at 43 Kasey Pass to Bevalie McFarland for $360,000 GALWAY Leigh Novak sold property at 5557 Lake Rd to Jason Haribans for $339,900 Heidi Gifford sold property at 1123 Rt 29 to 123 Rt 29 Land Trust for $100,000 John Warholic sold property at 5278 Sacandaga Rd to Jessica Morris for $100,000 GREENFIELD Samuel Ellis sold property at 25 Lady Slipper Lane to Michael Folmsbee for $165,000 MALTA  Thomas Ruby sold property at 35 Hills Rd to Christie Burdick for $440,000 Jennifer Kotch sold property at 31 George Ave to Zacharay Sedefian for $315,000 MILTON…