Opinion - Saratoga Springs Politics

The below blog posts are written by John Kaufmann.
These opinions do not reflect the views of Saratoga TODAY newspaper.

Thursday, 25 May 2023 09:36

Minita Sangvhi Goes All In with Moran and Kim In Their Feud With Montagnino

By John Kaufmann | Saratoga Springs Politics
Minita Sangvhi Goes All In with Moran and Kim In Their Feud With Montagnino

Is The Public Served By More Media Coverage of the Petty and Foolish Conflicts Among Our Public Officials?

Saratoga Springs Finance Commissioner Minita Sanghvi went to WRGB TV in an apparent embarrassing attempt to polish her credentials as a staunch ally of Mayor Ron Kim and Accounts Commissioner Dillon Moran in their dispute with Public Safety Commissioner James Montagnino.

Commissioner Sanghvi shared with WRGB TV her criticism of Commissioner Montagnino over the presence of police standing by in the stairwell to the Music Hall as a raucous Black Lives Matters demonstration was disrupting the City Council meeting on May 2.

She felt the police presence at the May 2nd meeting was unnecessary use of police overtime.

“Seven or eight police officers in the back staircase, I don't think they were needed, nobody seemed to be showing signs of violence,” said Sanghvi. “There were Kids protesting, but that’s what kids do, they protest.”

Channel 6 News May 16, 2023

According to Commissioner Sanghvi, the mayor’s office is requesting that Montagnino provide a report showing police overtime hours for council meetings.

channel 6 News May 16, 2023

Tone Deaf

With all due respect, Commissioner Sanghvi is no expert on risk assessment.

She appears somehow oblivious to the potential danger that exists when situations get out of control, as they did on May 2 when BLM demonstrators brought the City Council meeting once more to a halt. She ignores how other audience members might react to the protesters' aggressive taunts and name-calling in this volatile situation.

Her dismissal of BLM's behavior by saying, "They were kids protesting, but that’s what kids do, they protest,” sends an interesting message to Lex Figuereo who is in his mid-thirties and probably doesn't see the BLM protests as a playful, somewhat frivolous adolescent experiment.

It is rather stunning that Commissioner Sanghvi does not see the potential for someone being hurt in this polarized world we now live in. It appears that for her, the events of May 2 were just innocent theater that no one should find upsetting. The idea that some disturbed person might be prompted to violence against the public attending the meeting, members of the Council, or BLM is lost on her.

Her animus with Commissioner Montagnino seems to have blinded her to the fact that Chief Crooks deployed the men and women of the police department because he reasonably believed that the situation could put the lives of everyone, including Commissioner Sanghvi, at risk.

Making the situation even more strange is Mayor Kim's contradictory behavior in all this. The now infamous epithet-laden confrontation between Kim and the Deputy Commissioner of Public Safety was over Kim's allegation that he had been threatened in an email sent by an individual who, it turns out, routinely attends Council meetings. In fact, he was in attendance at the May 2 meeting. Given their fears (baseless or not), you would think that Sanghvi, Kim, and Moran would have been relieved to know that the police would be available.

Sanghvi's alleged sudden concern with overtime expenses for police is also hard to take seriously when Sanghvi has repeatedly had no problem approving payments for all sorts of dubious additions to the city's budget including additions to other Council members' staff and her own staff, payments of all kinds of legal bills as the Mayor pursues frivolous lawsuits, and of course redecorating her office.

No, this TV appearance seems to truly be nothing more than a petty continuation of the alliance of Kim, Sanghvi, and Moran against Public Safety Commissioner Montagnino.

Read 742 times


  • Saratoga County Court  Justin P.  Rodriguez was sentenced Sept. 14 in Saratoga County Court to an aggregate maximum term of 22-1/2 years in state prison in connection with actions that caused the death of Alex Bleickhardt, Saratoga County District Attorney Karen Heggen said in a statement. The incident involved a fatal crash along I-87 (the Northway) in Wilton on Sept. 15, 2022 when the 42-year-old Rodriguez approached a disabled box truck and a heavy-duty tow truck on the shoulder of the road, and making no effort to move over, slow down, or avoid a collision, rear-ended the box truck at 76…

Property Transactions

  • BALLSTON Edward Swanson sold property at 234 Round lake Rd to Amanda Dealo for $275,000 Brookview Court Inc sold property at 31 Arcadia Ct to Megan McCormack for $356,469 Kathryn Schneider as trustee sold property at 7 Sycamore St to Terri Allen for $401,500 CORINTH Louis Faraone sold property at 91 Main St to Michaela Bovee for $220,000 Brendon Emery sold property at 1 Mill Creek Rd to Paul Posson for $410,000 GALWAY Lisa Letourneau sold property at 2467 Galway Rd to Jason Barnes for $402,000 Frederick Puliafico sold property at 3011 South Shore Dr to Joann Gallucci for $235,000…